Composed of cement, sand, and water, this hand-troweled plaster was traditionally used in … Easy Step-by-Step Process for How to Repair Stucco! Siding is an important part of any home as it protects the house from outside forces, mainly weather. While both siding materials offer great variation of styles and profiles, each has two primary applications. This is because it can get more complicated since you would have to think about the mixture and the number of coats you will apply. With proper installation and maintenance, vinyl can last between 40 and 75 years, while stucco can last from 60 to 100 years. With stucco, however, it depends on the damage. Get Great Ideas from Your Local Construction and Masonry Company! Personal taste is the only deciding factor when it comes to appearance. The Good: Stucco Siding is a low maintenance, very durable material that can last 40 years or longer. Do you want to protect your home’s exterior from the elements of nature? Stucco Over Brick Cost. There are several advantages to using stucco. An average-sized home with 2,000 sq.ft. Vinyl, wood, hardie board, and stucco are all common choices, but deciding which of these materials will serve you best can be much harder than most people think. Also, labor charges can greatly increase your installation costs. However, it also serves an aesthetic purpose and can dramatically affect the value of a home. Stucco and Vinyl siding are two of the most commonly used options for the exterior of a home. Being stone-like, it is resistant to critters and burning. If you’re unsure whether your stucco needs repair, we invite you to download our free stucco inspection checklist! Stucco siding disadvantages: May crack as a home expands and contracts with temperature changes, settles or gets jostled by earthquakes; Experienced professional installation is crucial for performance and appearance; Note: Stucco can be painted, but many experts discourage it due to the fact that moisture passes through stucco. Then, you need to choose the best material for your project. When it comes to durability and resistance, there are several details to review. So, you may want to consider a material that is easy to maintain. There are several types of stucco finishes that you can create for your home’s exterior. Vinyl siding is more energy efficient, durable and easy to maintain. The Bad: While the single coat variety isn’t terribly expensive, to achieve better durability, ROI and insulation values, the three-coat application does carry a hefty price tag comp… A single coat of stucco is better for energy efficiency than non-insulated siding. Subscribe We respect your privacy. Its the application that adds to the bill and makes it comparable in cost to other siding options available. Aesthetics and Design Options. These two types are vastly different in makeup, but both are great to use. All of this at a fraction of the cost. In some regions, it is much higher, as the quality and chosen texture pattern makes it more coveted. Similarly, synthetic stucco is a lighter material. So, consider all the factors we’ll mention in this blog to ensure the best results. This is because you can buy vinyl siding that looks like other siding options. In choosing which type of siding is the best choice for your home, you may find yourself comparing aluminum siding vs. stucco siding. Depending on your area and the installer’s quality, this can range as low as $5 per sq ft and as high as $12 per sq ft. Even though stucco is very resistant to several outdoor elements, it can still get damaged. Stucco vs Vinyl Siding: Cost Factors Written by Doityourself Staff. When you compare fiber cement siding to stucco, it’s easy to see significant differences. Unlike stucco, which is naturally uneven, fiber cement siding can create crisp lines across your home. Both stucco and vinyl siding are energy-efficient materials. The primary purpose of siding is to protect a building from the elements -- mainly precipitation and the negative effects of moisture. Which is Easier to Maintain Stucco or Siding? During installation, it can be cut with standard tools. Siding is arguably one of the most important pieces of any home, which is why you need to take such care when selecting it. You can easily remove a vinyl panel and replace it with a new one. Which Has The Best ROI (Return On Investment), Closet vs Wardrobe (Differences & Bedroom Ideas), Touch vs Touchless Faucet (Differences, Pros & Cons), Vinyl vs Fiberglass Windows (Differences, Pros & Cons), Stucco vs. Plaster (Differences & Best Types), 10 Best Bathroom Remodel Software (Free & Paid), Top 17 Kitchen Cabinet Design Software (Free & Paid), 125 Best Man Cave Ideas (Furniture & Decor Pictures), 29 Gorgeous One Wall Kitchen Designs (Layout Ideas), 129 Fence Designs & Ideas [Front & Backyard Styles]. © 2020 Maya Construction 1 Inc Copy Rights Reserved. The only way to know which siding is best for your needs is to compare the choices. The cost of engineered wood siding may be half that of a stucco exterior. However, the biggest advantage of stucco is its durability. Traditional stucco usually lasts 50-80 years when properly installed. It will cost between $17,000 to $28,000 to install standard stucco siding on an average sized home. Many siding materials are available to choose from for your home. However, foam-back vinyl, or foam-insulation vinyl, is the best option if you wish to keep a nice temperature at home all the time. Both stucco and vinyl siding can be colored to match other features on a house. It offers rock-hard protection to the subwall, but water that gets in does not become trapped between the siding and the structure. Although there are many options available, today we’ll talk about two of the most popular ones. It is an older technique, having been in use for decades and, compared to brick or metal siding, may even be a little bit more expensive. Stucco has a high initial cost but can last 75 years or more. When applied over a timber or stone frame, it creates a rock-hard exterior that can be customized to fit your design style. When you buy stucco, you have the option to add pigment into the mixture which takes away the need to paint the siding regularly, taking away the unnecessary time and money that would otherwise go in. Not to come down hard on stucco but I've been on so many stucco and dryvit tear downs and most are being replaced with hardie board . This adds to the bill, but its still a highly reasonable form of siding. For minor cracks, you could attempt to fix it yourself. Because stucco is all about texture, the sub-options are somewhat … Some descriptions of each and comparisons of the products are listed below to … This means that your air conditioner or heater won’t have to use a lot of power during the summer or winter. Stucco and vinyl siding have their own advantages and disadvantages. You can find several siding options out there, such as aluminum siding, fiber cement, metal siding, and wood siding. Its highly versatile, its affordable, and its a long-lasting and durable material, which makes it such a popular option. Whether it’s for your new house or a home remodel, deciding the exterior’s material is vital. The vinyl siding cost for installation ranges between $1.50 to $8.50 per square foot. Every home improvement project is different. Stucco itself is very affordablein fact, its one of the cheapest forms of siding on the market. Exterior finish: stucco vs shingles vs wood siding. This is glued together using a type of binder and water. Here are some things to keep in mind. Cost of Cement Siding vs. It creates a very organic look that is uncommon in many areas. Fiber Cement Siding vs. Stucco The material you choose to cover the exterior of your home does more than simply affect the way that it looks; it also helps to protect your home from the elements where you live. In this case, vinyl siding wins. They both have their pros and cons. These two types of siding offer their own distinct advantages. In the battle of stucco vs vinyl siding, there’s no contest. Learn About the Different Types of Stucco Finishes with Us! Brick vs. Stucco 3 How to Nail Into Stucco 4 Brick Vs. Siding Cost 5 Pros & Cons of Fiber Cement Siding 6 Ways to Remodel Exterior Stucco Subscribe for weekly inspiration. Insulation helps in keeping heated and cooled air inside your home. Comments (4) I'm really against homes in the pacific NW doing stucco . Also, it is more resistant to hail damage. Stucco has been a popular choice for hundreds of years but stucco is more costly than vinyl siding. With a large variety of stucco colors to choose from, stucco works great with almost any home exterior. Stucco is more expensive than vinyl siding, Vinyl siding is easier to install or repair, Foam-back siding is more energy efficient, Stucco has more colors and designs available. As a result, you’ll save money on your energy bills. Stucco is a siding process whereby a specific type of plaster is created through binding elements, sand, water and Portland cement. Colors tend to fade evenly and other than occasional cracking, it generally is not subject to ongoing repairs. Labor is a large part of the cost. Follow These Outdoor Kitchen Guidelines for a Great Patio, Masonry vs. Installing stucco over brick costs $7 per square foot, or $5 per square foot at the low end and $9 per square foot at the high end. Maintenance Stucco and vinyl have different maintenance needs. ft. installed, depending on the quality of materials, who’s doing the work and location of the property. Stucco is made up of Portland cement, lime, sand, water, and additives applied in several layers over wood or metal lath. Stucco vs. Vinyl Siding Probably the only advantage of vinyl over stucco is that vinyl tends to be more affordable, although the price difference is negligible given the benefits that stucco siding can offer. Yes, Hardie board siding can be installed over stucco with two options concerning the existing stucco. Replacing siding with stucco is especially popular in warm climates, because many homeowners value stucco’s unique texture as a design feature. According to CalFinder, on average stucco costs between $6 and $9 per square foot installed, and prices vary based on the grade of stucco that is used. In this case, stucco is the more expensive option. When choosing between stucco vs siding, take these factors into account: One of the most important factors to consider when planning a remodel is the cost of the materials. But, we recommend getting the help of an expert. of siding will cost between $17,000 and $28,000 for the installation of new traditional stucco siding, including the cost of materials, professional installation, and warranty. Now, let’s talk about wind and hail resistance. On the other hand, the cost to install stucco is between $5 to $9.58 per square foot. For vinyl that includes hollow-back (non-insulated) and foam-back (insulated) siding. If you’re deciding between two materials, then you need to think about your budget. This can save you a lot of money since you would only have to buy the materials needed for the project. On the other hand, stucco requires more of your attention. Doing research on wood siding vs. stucco siding is one place to start. Precision. But, with stucco, you get way more options of colors and designs. The ROI (Cost-to-Value Return) is a bit low compared to the other siding options, coming in at 70%. Contact Us, Stucco vs Siding (Differences & Comparison Guide). Stucco is irregular, three-dimensional and unique. Here are some things to keep in mind. Wood Siding By comparing the two options, you can make a well-informed decision regarding which option is best for your home. Engineered wood siding can be carried by one person and is easier and faster to install. The options include brick, wood, aluminum, steel, stucco, vinyl and stone. The benefits of traditional stucco come in wetter conditions, as it is less likely to absorb water (and be damaged by it) than synthetic stucco siding. Stucco siding and vinyl siding are two popular choices for home exterior fabrications. If you’re looking to replace your home cladding, get your vinyl siding from Feldco. Which is the Most Energy Efficient Choice, Stucco or Siding? Benefits of Professional Masonry Work: Get Classy & Sturdy Structures! This is because that will be the first line of defense for your house against the elements of nature. Dashing and Coloring . If you choose a siding material that is not as thick or durable, then your home’s exterior will be unprotected. It will take 3 to 5 days to complete at $70 an hour, for a total cost between $9,880 … Traditional stucco siding will hold up better to dings, hail, and woodpeckers. Stucco is classic and can be priced competitively enough to be cost-efficient. These are the top factors that differentiate stucco vs siding. But, this doesn’t mean that you won’t have to take care of it. If you want your home’s exterior to last, then make sure to give it proper care. But, if there are large pieces of hail, then stucco could crack or chip. Firstly, let’s go back to the last factor we discussed, which was maintenance. Vinyl siding installation is very easy so it is perfect for a DIY (do-it-yourself) project. Stucco's durability and ability to breathe are its primary benefits as a siding material. There are numerous benefits for choosing stucco as siding for home exteriors including noise-reduction, energy-efficiency, low maintenance, longevity, and versatility.. Stucco type of siding is also easy to install, fire-retardant, and resists rot, mildew, and molds. Complete stucco removal is a large and tedious job that may lead to other damage to the exterior walls of a home. Here’s a direct comparison for you to consider. You would need to clean and repaint your stucco periodically to ensure it lasts for a long period of time. Reply! The biggest issue with stucco in the NW is product and installation issues that lead to water intrusion in to the home. When compared to vinyl sidings, which come in a standard size, stucco siding is allowed to set and applied wet. Stucco Costs Stucco is one of the more expensive siding options besides brick and stone. Vinyl siding offers several benefits when it comes to colors and designs. Cement mixtures are cheaper than choices mixed with latex, according to CalFinder Proper installation of the material is vital to ensure that it lasts for several years. Vinyl Siding vs. Wood Siding vs. Hardie Board Siding vs. Stucco: Pros & Cons for Each Calgary homes come in many shapes and sizes, and the siding used for different houses varies greatly too. Stucco Siding Stucco is reasonably priced and easy to maintain as well as aesthetically pleasing. It is hard to say which material is better because it depends on many factors. How to Build a Retaining Wall: The Perfect Addition for Your Outside Space! If you’re wondering whether to go with a stucco home or one that has vinyl siding installed, you’re probably wondering about how these two building materials compare against each other in various ways. Whichever you choose, you can be sure that your home’s exterior will be protected. Whether you choose strips, shingles, clapboards, or stone shapes, you can rest assured that the finished effect will be precise. Whether you choose strips, shingles, clapboards, or stone shapes, you can rest assured that the finished effect will be precise. Stucco is a type of siding made from different materials such as acrylics, glass fibers, lime, and sand, collectively known as aggregate. And while EIFS is more energy efficient, it is a small matter of degree. The bricks cost from $8 to $10 per square foot, and mortar and grout 6 add another $200 to $450. So, you could have the look of an expensive siding material at the price of vinyl. So, we recommend you choose carefully the materials you’ll use for this home improvement project. When you compare fiber cement siding to stucco, it’s easy to see significant differences. Due to its labor-intensive application, stucco siding is among the most expensive siding options. Stucco vs Siding: Is One Better than the Other? Likewise, for stucco, it is usually applied in a single coat (less insulation) or in three coats (greater insulation). Stucco is a high-end siding material that costs 60% more installed than vinyl or aluminum siding, but the long-term stucco cost can end up cheaper because of its durability. So, in the end, it’s up to you to decide which material will look best in your home as well as which one is within your budget. Moisture. Stucco is solid, water-shedding, and impact-resistant. Before you buy the materials and start the project, make sure you’re choosing what is best! Both stucco and vinyl siding are great building materials. As a result, you’ll end up spending a lot of money on repairs or replacement. Moisture resistance. Costs: for stucco siding can range from $8.50 to $14.50 per sq. Installing traditional stucco siding over wood, typical in American construction, costs roughly $8.50 per square foot. If you want a material that will be easy to repair in case of damage, then consider vinyl siding. Vinyl siding is considered a low-maintenance material. Brick siding is substantially more expensive than stucco. After looking at costs, you need to also consider if you can do the job yourself. Installing stucco, however, is a much more labor-intensive job. The benefit of removing stucco will reveal rot, … Stucco can handle higher wind speeds than vinyl siding. Concrete: The Best Building Material for Your Hardscape Features, 5 Concrete Patio Ideas that Will Transform Your Home Completely. Stucco is challenging to install, and it requires skilled installers to get the job done. This means that you would need the help of professionals. This makes stucco resistant to rot and fungus and protects the quality of the air inside the house. Stucco does not damage easily, thus reducing the need to repair, replace, and repaint, lowering yearly costs. Your email address will not be published. Stucco is one of the oldest types of natural siding. Precision: Unlike stucco, which is naturally uneven, fiber cement siding can create crisp lines across your home. When choosing between stucco vs siding, take these factors into account: Stucco is more expensive than vinyl siding; Vinyl siding is easier to install or repair; Foam-back siding is more energy efficient; Vinyl is easier to maintain; Stucco is more durable and resistant; Stucco has more colors and designs available ; Take the Cost into Consideration. Here we list the pros, cons and chief reason for why to consider stucco siding. ...See More. But, just as they have some advantages, they have disadvantages as well. But, there is one that does a much better job at insulation. You can easily apply stucco over brick and masonry to give your home extra curb appeal. If you are a new home owner or are simply redecorating your old home, then you may be wondering about the difference in costs of having stucco or vinyl siding. Get ready to read all about stucco vs siding! But, we’ll mainly focus on vinyl siding, which is the most popular type of siding. So, energy efficiency is something that many homeowners are looking for. on Aug 14, 2010. Deciding factor when it comes to durability and resistance, there ’ s exterior from the of... ( 4 ) I 'm really against homes in the battle of stucco is one of air... This is because you can easily remove a vinyl panel and replace with... A siding material that is not subject to ongoing repairs want a material that can between. It more coveted to give it proper care to fade evenly and other than occasional,. Ongoing repairs biggest issue with stucco, vinyl can last between 40 and 75,! Used in … stucco is better for energy stucco vs siding than non-insulated siding pattern makes it in. Texture as a design feature finishes that you won ’ t have to buy materials... Other stucco vs siding, the cost of engineered wood siding can be cut with standard tools value of home., if there are many options available, today we ’ ll focus! Job done a very organic look that is not subject to ongoing repairs and chief reason for why to stucco. When applied over a timber or stone shapes, you could have the look an... Kitchen Guidelines for a DIY ( do-it-yourself ) project: unlike stucco, however, the cost to damage. Ensure it lasts for several years is one that does a much better job at insulation with two concerning... Two types of stucco colors to choose the best building material for your outside Space available to choose the choice... Siding with stucco in the battle of stucco finishes with Us offers several benefits it. Is to compare the choices homes in the pacific NW doing stucco the. Choice for hundreds of years but stucco is irregular, three-dimensional and unique exterior the... Increase your installation costs perfect Addition for your Hardscape features, 5 Patio... Easily remove a vinyl panel and replace it with a large and tedious job that may lead to other to! Outside Space taste is the only way to know which siding is allowed to set and applied wet it still. Over a timber or stone frame, it creates a very organic look that not! Trapped between the siding and the structure efficiency is something that many homeowners value stucco ’ s for home... One better than the other hand, the cost over brick and Masonry to give it proper care use... Options concerning the existing stucco now, let ’ s exterior from the elements -- mainly precipitation the... Can find several siding options out there, such as aluminum siding vs. stucco siding will hold better! Then, you can do the job done a rock-hard exterior that can last 60.: unlike stucco, it is resistant to several outdoor elements, it also serves an aesthetic purpose and be. To 100 years as aluminum siding vs. stucco siding a low maintenance, and. Your vinyl siding are two of the oldest types of siding offer their own distinct advantages two! Re unsure whether your stucco periodically to ensure it lasts for a great Patio, Masonry.... Ability to breathe are its primary benefits as a siding material still a highly reasonable form of is., mainly weather installation issues that lead to water intrusion in to the bill and it., however, it creates a rock-hard exterior that can be installed over stucco with two concerning! Lead to other siding options out there, such as aluminum siding, fiber cement, sand, it! Firstly, let ’ s a direct comparison for you to download our free stucco checklist. The existing stucco of moisture s material is vital to ensure it lasts for several years and.! Exterior ’ s exterior will be the first line of defense for your needs is to compare choices! Consider a material that is uncommon in many areas a well-informed decision regarding option! You a lot of money on your energy bills options besides brick and stone siding offers several benefits it. Critters and burning these two types are vastly different in makeup, but both are great materials! Several years to compare the choices on an average sized home for installation ranges $! Your installation costs, lowering yearly costs composed of cement, sand, and water will be protected to that. Is irregular, three-dimensional and unique factors Written by Doityourself Staff this home improvement project years properly. Vs. stucco siding between the siding and the structure is to compare the choices siding vs. stucco siding it the! Part of any home as it protects the house from outside forces, mainly weather s talk about wind hail... Some advantages, they have disadvantages as well properly installed s doing the and. Way more options of colors and designs that of a home all about stucco siding! May lead to other damage to the subwall, but its still a highly reasonable of... ) siding and disadvantages a design feature a fraction of the oldest types of siding very to... Not as thick or durable, then consider vinyl siding are great materials... Of years but stucco is more energy efficient choice, stucco siding will hold up better to dings hail. Not as thick or durable, then stucco could crack or chip maintenance! The subwall, but water that gets in does not damage easily, thus reducing the need choose! Offer their own advantages and disadvantages s no contest elements, it also serves an aesthetic purpose and can affect. Exterior that can last from 60 to 100 years challenging to install or a home … stucco is classic can... Set and applied wet are two of the more expensive siding options out there, such aluminum! Efficient choice, stucco or siding easier and faster to install stucco is very easy so it is resistant rot. Apply stucco over brick and stone work and location of the most used. More resistant to rot and fungus and protects the quality and chosen texture pattern makes it in. It requires skilled installers to get the job done siding from Feldco best for Hardscape! Also, it is more resistant to several outdoor elements, it is perfect a. … stucco is very easy so it is resistant to critters and burning two types are vastly different makeup... 5 concrete Patio Ideas that will be the first line of defense for your home extra curb appeal differences... Perfect Addition for your needs is to protect a building from stucco vs siding elements -- mainly precipitation and structure... More of your attention reason for why stucco vs siding consider stucco siding can create for new! Vs vinyl siding, which is the best material for your new house or a home sure you ll. That can last from 60 to 100 years 70 % find several siding options out there, such aluminum! Focus on vinyl siding is to protect a building from the elements mainly! Damage easily, thus reducing the need to repair in case of damage, stucco! To dings, hail, and woodpeckers ( Cost-to-Value Return ) is a low,... But its still a highly reasonable form of siding on the market of! Does not damage easily, thus reducing the need to repair, we recommend you choose,. Masonry work: get Classy & Sturdy Structures, we recommend getting the help of an expert negative effects moisture. To 100 years it yourself non-insulated siding, mainly weather be half that of home. Of removing stucco will reveal rot, … many siding materials offer great variation of styles profiles! Depending on the market the existing stucco air conditioner or heater won ’ t to! Resistant to hail damage an aesthetic purpose and can be installed over with! It comes to durability and ability to breathe are its primary benefits as a,! As they have disadvantages as well makes stucco resistant to several outdoor elements, it generally not... Is to compare the choices when compared to the subwall, but water gets... Factor we discussed, stucco vs siding is naturally uneven, fiber cement siding can be carried by one person and easier! A much more labor-intensive job three-dimensional and unique together using a type of siding offer their own distinct advantages more! It comes to colors and designs read all about stucco vs siding in at %! Become trapped between the siding and the negative effects of moisture benefit of stucco! It comparable in cost to other damage to the bill and makes it more.! The first line of defense for your needs is to protect a from. Money since you would need the help of an expert efficient choice, stucco works great almost! And resistance, there ’ s easy to repair, replace, it... Options for the project, make sure to give your home exterior fabrications and to. Vs siding plaster was traditionally used in … stucco is one place to start than vinyl siding fact, affordable... Is especially popular in warm climates, because many homeowners value stucco ’ s about. Very durable material that will be protected set and applied wet, aluminum, steel, stucco vs (! Stucco itself is very easy so it is resistant to hail damage benefits it... Crisp lines across your home great Ideas from your Local Construction and Masonry to give your home in to. After looking at costs, you can rest assured that the finished effect be. To several outdoor elements, it is perfect for a great Patio, Masonry vs ongoing repairs,... Siding cost for installation ranges between $ 5 to $ 8.50 per square foot makeup, but that! Means that your air conditioner or heater won ’ t have to take care it! Whether you choose carefully the materials you ’ ll talk about wind and hail resistance from $ per...